top of page
Writer's picturevoiceforus

SUSAN E. KELLY, with a history of hoarding animals, charged with dozens of counts of animal neglect

- New York, USA -


On Wednesday, August 10, 2022, Fulton County Sheriff’s Office Investigators arrested 70-years-old SUSAN E. KELLY (pictured).


The sheriff’s office said in a press release that the arrest is the result of an investigation into an animal neglect case.

The case involved animals living in inadequate shelter, poor living conditions, and were malnourished due to lack of food and water readily available to them”, stated the release.


The investigation was initially launched after complaints of a loose dog at a residence located at State Highway 349 in Mayfield that is occupied by KELLY.

The complaints then led to larger concerns about animals at the property and on July 25, 2022, the Fulton County Sheriff’s Office executed a search warrant.


In a press release of July 26, 2022, the Fulton County Regional SPCA said that KELLY’s property “is home toKelly's Havenarescue organizationwith a history of animal hoarding and cruelty complaints spanning over decades.”


Officials discovered approximately:


52 dogs; 50 living, 2 deceased

2 goats

2 rabbits

1 horse

Over a dozen ducks and chickens


The poor animals were found to be living “primarily outdoors and in filthy uninhabitable conditions. Clean water and appropriate shelter were scarce”, said , the Fulton County Regional SPCA.


The seizure of the VOICELESS VICTIMS was led and organized by both the James A. Brennan Memorial Humane Society and Fulton County Regional SPCA with sheltering assistance from Ayres Memorial Shelter.

The poor souls were evaluated and treated by veterinarians and placed in the care of the above-mentioned agencies.


On August 10, 2022, a Facebook post by James A. Brennan Memorial Humane Society read: “The animals continue to receive necessary care. Our legal counsel is preparing to file for a security bond in this matter to ensure that the defendant pays for the care and housing of the animals during the pendency of the criminal matter or seeking their forfeiture to either us (James A. Brennan Memorial Humane Society) or the SPCA.”


The Fulton County Sheriff's Office said that KELLY was charged with fifty-five counts of torturing or injuring animals/failure to provide sustenance, which is a Class A Misdemeanor.

She was issued appearance tickets to appear at the Town Of Mayfield court at a later date.


The picture of the two dogs was shared from Ayres Memorial Animal Shelter.


On a separate note, The Daily Gazette reports that: “Kelly was the subject of an animal cruelty case in 2011. During that case, the Sheriff’s Department said it had received multiple complaints about the property. At that time, around 300 animals were found on the propertyfrom dogs and cats to livestock and parrots. In that case, the animals had been receiving food, but the living conditions were below standard and a small number of the animals had to have emergency care.”


Voice For Us Disclaimer: This story is sourced from official news outlets. Links included.

Details may be removed or additional information may be provided in future should such sources report an update.






30 views1 comment

1 comentario


Judy A Canon
Judy A Canon
15 ago 2022

Susan Kelly history involves at least two episodes of animal neglect. Why then was she allowed to open a ‘haven’ the second time? Was she receiving donations for a non-profit then / now? I am so glad these poor souls were rescued. RIP TWO PRECIOUS SOULS for which help arrived too late. This woman should not be allowed to ever to pretend to help any animals for the rest of her life.

Me gusta
bottom of page